Costco's U.S. comparable sales jumped 12.6% in October, and its membership base keeps growing. The Motley Fool's Neil Patel sees a widening moat, but argues the stock's valuation makes it hard to buy.
Costco's comparable sales in the U.S. jumped 12.6% year over year in October, covering the four weeks that ended Nov. 1. Excluding gasoline sales and foreign exchange, the figure rose 8.1%.
Membership growth anchors the moat
Patel points to one metric as proof the moat is widening: members. At the end of fiscal Q4 2026, which ended Aug. 30, Costco reported 84.1 million membership households, up 3.8% year over year and 36% over five years. Patel believes this shows a sticky customer base that brings in recurring membership revenue.
The company keeps growing despite its size. It posted $24.5 billion in October net revenue and runs more than 900 warehouses globally. Rivals include Walmart's Sam's Club and BJ's Wholesale Club, and Amazon's Prime membership also competes for shoppers.
Scale also gives Costco leverage over suppliers. The average warehouse sells 4,000 stock-keeping units, against 30,000 at typical supermarkets, so Costco buys large volumes of fewer goods and passes savings to shoppers.
Rising inflation may push shoppers toward warehouses
Patel notes that inflation is rising more than expected. In that setting, he says, joining Costco seems like a no-brainer for households focused on value, which drives more sign-ups. Chief executive Ron Vachris says Costco is gaining market share even though consumers remain under pressure.
A price-to-earnings ratio of 53.5 clouds the case
Valuation is where Patel hesitates, and he frames it through the P/E ratio. Costco's now sits at 53.5, versus 46.7 five years ago. The stock has climbed 114% in the last five years and moved 24% higher in the past two months, when the P/E ratio started at 43.1.
Patel says he believes the company is uninvestable right now, because paying a big premium to the market is hard to justify even though the business has staying power.
Source: The Motley Fool
Trading involves risk.