A SpaceX-Tesla merger would need a yes from more than half of all Tesla shares, not just a majority of votes cast. Retail ownership, proxy adviser opposition, possible lawsuits and antitrust scrutiny add to the hurdles. Market pricing suggests lower odds of an announcement by December 31.
A SpaceX-Tesla merger needs approval from more than half of Tesla's 3.95 billion outstanding shares, so every abstention works as a vote against. Winning the majority of votes cast at a shareholder meeting would not be enough.
Tesla's voting math is harder than it looks
Elon Musk is the largest shareholder in both companies and wants to merge them. Still, Musk owns 19.8% of Tesla, based on the latest DEF14A filing, and the 10 largest institutional investors hold another 22.3%.
Tesla also has significant retail ownership, which could make it challenging to collect enough yes votes. In addition, proxy adviser Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) recommended against Musk's nearly $1 trillion pay plan in 2025 and against Musk-endorsed board members. SpaceX shareholders must approve the deal as well.
Courts and regulators could step in
No lawsuits have been filed so far to block the deal. Tesla also reincorporated in Texas, where shareholder lawsuits are more restricted than in Delaware. The source says the lack of suits reflects that the two companies have not announced a formal merger agreement.
Antitrust regulators could also intervene. Tesla's rivals could face a disadvantage if Tesla gains exclusive access to SpaceX technology such as Starlink.
Markets price lower odds of a near-term announcement
Tesla's annual meeting takes place on December 3, but no merger item is on the agenda. Market participants appear to view the hurdles as making an announcement less likely in the near term, with the December 31 contract priced at 16.5%.
Tesla shares closed at $374.41, down 2.43%, giving the company a market cap of $1.48 trillion.
Wedbush's Dan Ives puts the probability that the merger goes through at 80% to 90%, while The Motley Fool's author suspects the chances are lower, though still in favor of the deal.
Sources: The Motley Fool, Crypto Briefing
Trading involves risk.