Automated bots attacked deliberately vulnerable Bitcoin addresses within seconds after University of Liège researchers exposed a signing error. A scan of six blockchains recovered 3,620 private keys. The researchers did not establish how much money was actually stolen.
Two Belgian researchers made a very old wallet mistake on purpose, and the bots showed up within seconds. Vincent Jacquot and Benoît Donnet, computer scientists at the University of Liège, put $3 to $5 each into Bitcoin and Ethereum accounts that they had deliberately left vulnerable.
On Bitcoin, the attacks began, Jacquot told CoinDesk: "a second or a few seconds after the bait was set up." At least two rival transactions raced to claim the coins while they sat in the mempool, where transactions wait before the network confirms them.
How a reused nonce gives away a key
Every signature relies on a random number, called a nonce, that is supposed to be used only once. If the same secret key signs two transactions with the same nonce, anyone who sees both can work out the key and take the money.
The researchers sent 7,200 satoshis to each of six newly created addresses. About an hour later, two of those addresses paid each other using the same nonce, which revealed nothing because two different keys had signed. Then one of the pair signed a third payment with that nonce, and the math to unlock it was available to anyone.
Next, that address sent its remaining 5,200 satoshis to a stranger. The transaction was signed with the bait's own private key and landed in a block nine minutes later.
3,620 keys recovered across six chains
Jacquot and Donnet scanned every ECDSA signature on six blockchains through June 30, 2024. They recovered 3,620 private keys, and 3,278 of them came from the Bitcoin blockchain. Dogecoin accounted for 195, Ethereum for 119, Litecoin for nine, Bitcoin Cash for six and Dash for one.
The researchers valued each vulnerable address's highest balance at prices from Nov. 25, 2024. The peaks added up to €101 million, about $106 million, according to Jacquot. However, the calculation assumes an attacker reached every address at its richest moment, and the team did not establish how much was actually stolen.
Most of that exposure dates to bitcoin's early years. The vulnerable pot peaked near $26 million in December 2014.
Attackers appear to skip some chains. The authors found that Dogecoin, Dash and Litecoin are likely not under active scrutiny by attackers.
Source: CoinDesk
Trading involves risk.