MSCI will delete Strategy and Metaplanet from its indexes at the close of Nov. 30. Strategy calls the screening method pretextual, while the stock trades at a discount to its Bitcoin holdings. The screen could give other index providers a template for hitting more crypto treasury stocks.
MSCI made the decision official on Nov. 11: Strategy, the software company turned Bitcoin treasury, leaves the MSCI USA Index at the close of Nov. 30. Japan-based Metaplanet is also on its way out, and Ethereum treasury company SharpLink lands on a new public watch list.
A fight that has run for more than a year
The decision caps a dispute that has run for more than a year. In October 2025, MSCI proposed excluding any company whose digital-asset holdings made up 50% or more of total assets. More than 250 organizations objected, and MSCI dropped the idea in January.
In August, MSCI returned with a broader screen aimed at non-operating companies, built on five financial-ratio flags. A company that trips four of them is out.
Strategy pushes back
According to Strategy's formal response, the proposal is "pretextual", suggesting MSCI may be inventing reasons to exclude it. The letter says Strategy alone makes up about 87% of the market value affected across all six names on the exclusion list. Strategy also says its Bitcoin business is an operating segment of an established software company.
Yet the same 10-page letter says the exclusion would have no meaningful impact on Strategy's business. On Nov. 19, Strategy held an investor call, and the index removal never came up.
Strategy trades below its Bitcoin value
Strategy held 850,849 Bitcoin as of Nov. 20, about 4.05% of all that will ever exist, worth roughly $55.1 billion. Its multiple of net asset value stands at 0.98x, and the stock is down 54.5% over the past year.
Funds that track MSCI benchmarks, including any index fund built on them, face a deadline. They will have to sell their Strategy and Metaplanet shares by the end of November, and some of that selling was likely priced in after the August proposal.
The bigger issue is precedent. S&P Dow Jones Indices has not adopted MSCI's screen, but others could follow the template. Any company that builds its balance sheet around a single digital asset may find the passive-investing bid is not a given.
Source: The Motley Fool
Trading involves risk.