J.P. Morgan analyst Rajat Gupta believes Tesla's robotaxi fleet could match Waymo's in cumulative autonomous miles by the end of 2027. The Motley Fool's Lee Samaha argues that total cost of ownership per mile matters more, and that Tesla holds the edge on it.
J.P. Morgan analyst Rajat Gupta believes that Tesla's robotaxi fleet could match Alphabet's Waymo fleet in cumulative autonomous miles by the end of 2027. Such an event would mark a milestone in Tesla's robotaxi development.
Still, Motley Fool writer Lee Samaha argues that miles are not the key metric. He says a different number will arguably determine Tesla's overall value.
The cost per mile target
That number is total cost of ownership (TCO) per mile. At the 2024 We, Robot event, Elon Musk put the Cybercab's operating cost at "probably going to be $0.20" per mile, with a Cybercab cost of $30,000, according to the Motley Fool.
Those are Tesla's own costs, however. Anyone who buys a Cybercab to run as a robotaxi must also factor in the $299-per-month full self-driving subscription, according to Samaha. If a Cybercab runs 300,000 miles, four years of subscriptions could come to $14,352.
A $20,000 rival robotaxi shows a lower cost per mile
Samaha expects rivals to build low-cost electric vehicles with autonomous driving software, so margins could erode over time. He illustrates the point with a $30,000 Cybercab with a 300,000-mile life, which works out to $0.10 per mile in hardware cost. With $0.20 in operating costs, TCO comes to $0.30 per mile.
A rival robotaxi costing $20,000 with a 400,000-mile life comes to $0.05 per mile in hardware. Add the same $0.20 in operating costs and its TCO is $0.25 per mile.
Why Samaha expects Tesla to win
Samaha rejects the bear argument that rivals will eat into Tesla's advantage. First, he says Tesla's vision-only approach implies lower structural hardware costs than the LiDAR systems Waymo and others use. Second, autonomous driving software is not free, and robotaxis need to be purposely built for it, which adds costs for rivals.
Third, reaching $0.20-per-mile operating costs would require rivals to build the scale and operational learning that Tesla is doing now. Samaha adds that Tesla's miles under robotaxi expansion mean it is learning to reduce TCO per mile before others can.
Source: The Motley Fool
Trading involves risk.