A seasonality-based timing model suggests the stock market has an upside bias for the next two weeks, even after its worst week since April 2025. The model's long-term record is strong, but its short-term odds are not appreciably better than a coin flip.
Norman Fosback's "Seasonality Timing System" points to an upside bias in stocks between now and the first week of December, according to MarketWatch columnist Mark Hulbert. The signal arrives after the market's worst week since "liberation day" in April 2025.
What drives the two-week signal
Hulbert says the bias has nothing to do with the Santa Claus Rally. Instead, it traces to two seasonal patterns: the pre-Thanksgiving and turn-of-month tendencies.
Fosback created the system in the 1970s, and it relies only on the calendar. Followers stay in cash except for the few days around the turns of the month and just before exchange holidays. This time, the pre-Thanksgiving pattern begins at the close of this coming Monday and ends on the Friday after Thanksgiving. The turn-of-month pattern then takes over, so followers stay invested until Dec. 4's close.
History in a downturn
Hulbert says history does not support the worry that the signal may fail after a rough week. He notes the pattern has appeared even in prior years in the middle of a severe bear market. In the comparable two-week period of 2008, the market produced a 3.5% total return.
Hulbert lists several theories for the success. One holds that short sellers often cover before exchange holidays, to avoid upside risk when volume is light or exchanges are closed. Another points to retirement contributions that often go into equities around the turn of each month.
Since the start of 1982, the system has returned 10.5% annualized through the end of October, compared with 12.0% for buying and holding. It was in the market only a third of the time.
Caveats for short-term traders
Still, Hulbert warns that the system is built as a long-term strategy. Its odds of success over any short-term period are not appreciably better than a coin flip.
Source: MarketWatch
Trading involves risk.