S&P Global Ratings has cut its assessment of Tether's USDT from "4 (constrained)" to "5 (weak)". The agency points to riskier reserve assets and gaps in disclosure, while Tether disputes the report.
S&P Global Ratings cut its stablecoin assessment of USDT from a score of "4 (constrained)" to "5 (weak)" on November 26, 2025. The new score reflects S&P's view of how well Tether can keep the stablecoin pinned to the dollar.
What S&P flagged
The core issue is reserve quality. S&P counted Bitcoin, gold, secured loans and corporate bonds as higher-risk holdings, and together they made up 24% of Tether's reserves as of September 30, 2025, up from 17% a year earlier.
Bitcoin is where the margin gets thin. According to S&P's analysis, Bitcoin accounted for about 5.6% of USDT in circulation, while Tether's overcollateralization buffer was around 3.9%. If the Bitcoin slice fell sharply, the loss could exceed that buffer.
Disclosure was the second problem. S&P pointed to continuing gaps in information about custodians, counterparties and the exact makeup of the reserve assets.
Tether pushes back
Tether disputed the report, arguing that S&P relied on an outdated framework. According to Tether, that framework ignores USDT's resilience, its transparency and a track record of holding its peg over the past decade.
The company also points out that most of its reserves sit in short-term US Treasuries and cash equivalents.
USDC received a different verdict. S&P has given Circle's token a "strong" assessment, which places the two biggest dollar stablecoins at opposite ends of its scale.
The market impact so far
USDT circulation stood at about $184 billion around the time of the downgrade. Since then, it has moved between $175 billion and $180 billion, and the token has kept trading near $1.
The Bitcoin-versus-buffer gap is the figure to track. If Bitcoin keeps growing as a share of reserves while the buffer stays near 3.9%, the gap gets harder to defend.
Source: Crypto Briefing
Trading involves risk.